Between Autoeroticism and Heterotopia: Fellini's Amarcord

In Fellini, the characters' fantasy triumphs over reality
Federico Fellini is the icon of Italian cinema, and for many he is even the master of cinema in general. His influence is indeed omnipresent: it was he who first made the terms “vitelloni,” “paparazzi” and “la dolce vita” common currency. In the German-speaking world there is the fixed expression “der grosse Zampano” for men who carry themselves all too arrogantly, and in Italy people say “amarcord” when they refer sarcastically to something past. Indeed, even Fellini's first name, Federico, only became popular in Italy through his fame. Companies such as Fiat and Barilla use the music from Fellini films to harness the charm of bella Italia for themselves in commercials. One such pasta commercial by Barilla was, incidentally, my first, indirect encounter with Fellini.

Amarcord was made toward the end of Fellini's career and is considered his last really successful film. Long gone were the days of his beginnings in Rome as a caricaturist and neorealist filmmaker (La Strada, I Vitelloni). Neorealism understood itself as a political genre; it showed, unadorned, hard fates in poor milieus. But over time Fellini turned away from it: no longer the hard life on the “strada,” but rather the sweet and senseless life of the elite was what he showed in La dolce vita. With this scandalous film he had turned left-wing intellectuals and the Catholic Church against him in equal measure. In the 1960s he then became acquainted with psychoanalysis and began, with the Jungian Ernst Bernhard, to analyze himself and his dreams. During this time he also had a few experiences with LSD. His films thereupon lost entirely any claim to realism and political substance. He first worked through this creative reorientation with the self-ironic film Otto e mezzo, a creative crisis turned into film, and in the following decades created works as crazily motley as they were witty and brilliant, among them: Giulietta degli spiriti, Il Casanova, La città delle donne and his Satyricon. His style became carnivalesque, clownish and grotesque. Fantasy triumphed over realism. He cast young rebels, oddball figures of fun and sometimes even homeless people as actors for his films. Fellini's cinema had become a carnival.

On the making of Amarcord: it came to pass toward the end of the 1960s that Fellini lay in the hospital, mortally ill. At least the doctors there had declared him mortally ill. Fellini relied on connections and had a senior physician from his home region summoned through his contacts. This doctor did in fact make a much milder (and also correct) diagnosis, but more importantly: it was the first time in decades that Fellini heard the Romagnolo dialect of his homeland again. After the fear of death, a powerful feeling of nostalgia came over him instead. The term nostalgia, literally “the pain of home,” was coined to describe the feeling of Swiss mercenaries who longed for their homeland while abroad. So while it was originally understood as a purely spatial longing, nowadays it mostly means a temporal longing for the past. Fellini's nostalgia was in fact both: in the Second World War his hometown of Rimini was devastated so thoroughly that only 2% of the buildings were left standing. The city was then rebuilt with the help of the Americans, this time with enormous amusement facilities along the coast. Fellini visited Rimini only twice in all as an adult: once shortly after the war and then not until after that fateful hospital stay 20 years later. Nothing was left of his childhood in Rimini; Fellini really only recognized the dialect, so he writes. Everything was new; the city was more colorful and livelier than before, and above all more mixed.

But as Fellini watched the goings-on in the new Rimini, an unpleasant contrast struck him. While the young people there seemed liberal-minded, free-spirited and permissive, the old struck him by their tremendous uptightness. One morning he sees a young woman in a miniskirt walk across a piazza. Behind him two old men grumble something about how provocatively “such women” dress. He goes on quoting the men: “If you grab them and press them against the wall, the police come at once. But then why do they provoke like that?” Fellini is ashamed of his generation there. Of how they can imagine their desire only as rape – at best – and at worst even act on it in just that way. He ponders who or what caused these men of his generation to become so messed up. His positively tinged nostalgia for the Rimini of his childhood is thus joined by dark memories as well.

All this Fellini worked through creatively: he gave the result the name “Amarcord,” which in the dialect of his homeland means “I remember.” It is Fellini's own look into a lost past; what follows is a series of observations and analyses on it.

Amarcord is, I find, a highly ambivalent film. The music does lull us, conveys the charm of bella Italia mentioned at the outset, sings of positive nostalgia. Fellini himself, however, never in his life has a single positive word to say about the content of the film. According to him the film is about “rejection and desolation.” This ambivalence is not confined to Amarcord. Again and again Fellini's œuvre is praised for its humanism and its empathy. At the same time Fellini is criticized for how repulsive and immoral many of his characters are. That also applies to today's criticism of his depiction of women. One Fellini expert complains about a so-called “social justice movement” to which Fellini is now falling victim. I see it differently: in a conversation, a very committed feminist friend of mine, with whom I had already discussed morally questionable art, said: “Fellini? Fellini is my god.”

How do these different moods and judgments fit Fellini? I touched on it in the introduction: Fellini's cinema is a carnival. One can understand in different ways what this word means. I sum it up with the help of the literary theorist Mikhail Bakhtin. Carnivalesque is whatever gives the broad masses a voice, in such a way that those otherwise voiceless are also cheerfully audible; complete inclusion, so to speak. The carnivalesque does not discriminate; it laughs in every color and resists all criticism and interpretation. It is, moreover, a rebellious act; it overturns order, but without lastingly destroying it. More than that: through the dissolution and restoration of the normal order, that order is in the end reinforced. A carnival is always a deeply bodily, and thus human, act. The carnivalesque is not a lasting state but an occasion limited in time, whereby it in turn orders time and human togetherness. In Fellini's œuvre carnivals are omnipresent. They are among the reasons why Fellini's films possess few to no core messages. Bakhtin also writes that a carnival neither needs to nor can be analyzed at any great length. In Amarcord the carnival gives the film its form: the film is defined not by the plot but by the seasons, and these in turn by their festivals, that is, their carnivals. In summer there is the patriotic festival with the Fascist parade, in fall the car race and in spring the fogaraccia, at which the winter witch is burned. Adult life begins with the wedding feast and ends at the funeral; both mark the end of the film. At the festivals the whole of society is assembled, oversteps the bounds of decency and is in general thoroughly exuberant and silly. Even sillier than when the characters appear on their own.

Though that, in turn, does not apply to everyone. The funeral is of course not so cheerful (if nonetheless exaggerated with sentimentality), and a number of characters in Amarcord are really peculiar throughout, not only in the carnival scenes: they are always wild, impetuous, overdrawn and cracked. They are the second pillar of Felliniesque cinema: clowns. Fellini concerned himself with them all his life and also devoted a film of its own to them. The fairy-tale-telling street vendor, with his red nose and pale face, looks most like the clown he is. But there is one particular group of characters in the film that I can only explain to myself by interpreting them as clowns: I mean the teachers. How would a clown explain a pendulum to us? “Yes, it's like the clock, tick-tock, tick-tock!” The inebriated literature teacher marks difficult words with her moronic singsong – while the content is wrong from start to finish. When a clown speaks about the Fascist spirit, the pompous, parodying thunder must not be missing. Another teacher-clown talks and runs himself into such a rage that he disappears into the corner of the classroom. And who doesn't know them, the clown duos in which one is constantly annoyed by the dim-witted fellow clown who ruins the first one's act? I am thinking of the ancient Greek lesson. I see the school sequence as Fellini's attempt to work through traumatic episodes of his school days by presenting them as a series of aggressive clowneries. And bad teachers are traumatic in any case, especially when you are in conflict with them. Titta, Fellini's best friend, relates: “Federico was always honest, clever and direct. He was the opposite of his Fascist teachers.” So put yourself in Fellini's position. He watched as the backward rural population was indoctrinated into Fascism before his eyes by incompetent buffoons. In the moment that is of course anything but funny. The statement of a Fascist in the film during the interrogation, “We'll bash your skulls in until you finally understand that we only want what's best for you,” is likewise only really funny in retrospect; not in the situation itself in which Titta's father finds himself. If you filter out everything menacing about the Fascists with a nostalgic lens, what remains is precisely clowns. “We'll laugh about it later,” people say in German in especially unpleasant situations. That applies completely to Fellini's handling of his traumas. That is why we see bullying, sexual assault, political repression and even torture in the film without the emotional content that otherwise accompanies these things. Perhaps this sometimes makes Fellini seem inappropriate and morally borderline. But his way of creating is, I find, immortal: it could do us good, too, to take in current events and current ideas like a circus full of clowns.

Less clever than Fellini presumably was, but all the more direct, is the pupils' rebellion against the teachers. With toilet humor they raise a stink against the order of the school day, with fart noises against ancient Greek, with real feces against algebra. Nothing, after all, defuses Fascist pathos better than the carnal ingloriousness of the human body, to put it delicately. The children and the Fascists do, however, have something in common in the film. The school sequence begins with a horde of children storming around the corner. The authoritarian headmaster, growling, brings them to a halt. The Fascists likewise come running around a corner. They, by contrast, are not stopped. On the contrary, as they run they whirl up a cloud of fog and the people run after them in a daze. The parade is bodily, too: not only through physical exertion but also through raptures over the body of the Duce and through the sexual symbolism when the girls thrust their hoops and the boys their rifles into the air. And in any case, the Fascist parade follows on from the masturbation scene in the car. Fellini here makes obvious what Wilhelm Reich recognized early on in his text on the mass psychology of fascism:

Fascism is at once sexually charged and sexually repressive. According to Reich, fascism feeds on a rebelliousness, which among other things makes it necessary for fascism to foster sexual frustration, especially in young men – I often recognize this dynamic on today's internet. The compensatory activities for fascist man, such as soldierly brotherhood and those very parades, thereby acquire their erotic touch and rhythm. We get to feel this in that almost every scene of the film has strong sexual components, yet we do not get to see a single healthy and fulfilled sexuality. Impressive in this regard is the scene in which the carriage with prostitutes drives along the promenade. The melody “La cucaracha” is heard, while the camera, in a gliding shot, shows a cross-section of the society that is at once beguiled by the sight and yet has to keep away from the carriage. As you can see in this scene from the crucifixes in the background, which go on glowing long into the fade-out, the Catholic Church plays a central role in that dynamic of frustration. Very quickly, at the boys' confession, the priest comes to speak of masturbation. But here, too, the adolescents defy the strong arm of authority: in this scene we gain insight into their joint excursions to the victory monument or the farmers' market, both, in Felliniesque fashion, devoted to the admiration of backsides. And not least their meeting in the car, to tell one another their sexual objects while pleasuring themselves. The Church thus does not succeed in demonizing masturbation in the film, but through the attempt it achieves its actual goal: producing a sense of community. The adolescents celebrate their community in sin. And yet: their sexuality remains literally auto-erotic.

Poor Uncle Teo takes his frustration, again literally, to the very top. “Voglio una donna!” – he screams out what everyone else in the film thinks and feels. Yet he of all people has far fewer prospects of love and eroticism in life. What is interesting here is that Fellini's father grew up on just such a farm and that Fellini invokes this scene in order to call Amarcord a “film full of rejection.” Almost frightening, then, is the dim-witted farm child who hits himself while gawking at a donkey, as well as the boy who wants to murder his little sibling in the cradle. Somehow Uncle Teo, with his desperate rebellion, also fits the paternal farm; we do, after all, see the father resign himself completely. Teo may seem insane, but there is an interesting contrast between him and the German nobleman who visits the Grand Hotel (“Il Principe”). Both vogliono una donna, though the prince does not have to say so. More than that, he is offered a woman straightaway: Gradisca, who gets her nickname that night; literally, Gradisca means “Please help yourself.” How does that go together with what has been said so far? Of course it is a question of social class, but note also where this scene takes place. In the Grand Hotel, for what happens in the Grand Hotel stays in the Grand Hotel; it is just as with Las Vegas. The Grand Hotel and Vegas have one thing in common: they are heterotopias.

Forgive the theoretical detour, but Michel Foucault writes about a highly relevant phenomenon that he calls the heterotopia (literally: an other place). I have to introduce it briefly. These are spaces in a society that are separated from the rest, in which different kinds of people and things come together, and which have a transformative character. The Grand Hotel fits every one of Foucault's descriptions astonishingly well. Fellini himself tells of the real Grand Hotel, how in his eyes it was “at once Istanbul, Baghdad and Hollywood.” In the film, too, we hear and see all kinds of exotic things there, from Prussian generals to an oriental harem. As a boy Fellini projected every possible fantasy into this hotel, for there, so he says, they were possible in his eyes. Making possible what is unthinkable elsewhere is the main task of heterotopias. Projecting is a good keyword here, for according to Foucault the cinema, too, is a typical heterotopia. There Titta for once dares to approach the otherwise unattainable Gradisca. Foucault stresses that it is precisely taboo subjects that become possible in these other places: adultery in the motel, adolescence at summer camp. The most important heterotopia of a society: the ship. For it is a space with rules of its own and gives the rest of society the possibility of going away. Foucault writes: “In civilizations without boats, dreams dry up, espionage takes the place of adventure, and the police take the place of pirates.” For Foucault's theory of heterotopia sees such places of exception, as one might also call them, as stabilizing places, because they form exceptions to other rules. If they are taken away, society is robbed of its horizon and its freedom of soul; by this one can recognize the authoritarian character of a society. The Grand Hotel and the cruise ship Rex, the two central heterotopias of the film, have, seen in this light, something decisive in common in the film: the people of Rimini only look on from outside and have no other places of exception of their own. The historian does stress, after all, that he is the only one from his part of town who was ever in the Grand Hotel. The Fascists, by contrast, reserve access to the hotel for themselves. The adolescents, for their part, gape in, fascinated, from behind the hotel fence, and the outing onto the sea serves only to watch the Rex as it sails past. The ship “Rex” really existed, by the way, only it never sailed past Rimini, since it linked America and Italy and thus came only to Italy's west coast. Rimini lies in the east. Nevertheless, some people from Rimini claimed, after they had seen the film, to have watched the Rex in just this way back then. The scene thus symbolizes what the people of the Italian provinces missed: the connection to such international and liberal spaces as the Grand Hotel or America, the wide world.

What remains to the people in the film, however, is their fantasy. It is not a real space, but it has a certain power nonetheless. Precisely in connection with the hotel, the street vendor's fantasy is fascinating. It is able to overcome the boundary of the hotel and plunge into the longed-for fantasy world inside it. The adolescents, too, imagine in one scene that they are going to a ball at the Grand Hotel and then dance in the fog with women of their imagination. During the car race Titta dreams himself into a racing car together with the longed-for Gradisca. Quite similar, and above all an absolute high point both cinematically and emotionally, is the fantasy of the one boy that turns the Fascist parade into a wedding celebration with his adored Aldina. It is probably the core of Felliniesque cinema that the fantasy of the individual characters is empathetically acknowledged and celebrated. Indeed, that through this often carnivalesque fantasy the characters gain control over the narrative and can thus override every barrier. It is precisely through this that Fellini is extremely true to life, much more so than realist cinema could be.

And yet: fantasy cannot change reality. The people in the film remain frustrated in the end, their wishes unfulfilled. Yes, the film shows us carnivalesque scenes, but afterward there always follow those melancholy, empty scenes when the festivities dissolve. The reality ultimately remains that the characters endure a life that is repressive sexually as well as politically. The wedding feast is only partly a liberation from it: both Titta's mother and Gradisca have to leave their respective homes after marrying. It does not seem possible to come by love there in any other way. The sign at Gradisca's wedding promises “il paradiso,” which she is presumably seeking elsewhere – here, too, Foucault resonates with his theory of spaces.

The end of the film is then marked by farewells and dissolution. Gradisca was desired by all and thus provided a certain sense of community in the town. It should be mentioned here that Gradisca was a real, independent woman from a liberal milieu. Now she marries a carabiniere who proudly proclaims at the wedding: “Viva l'Italia!” At the end of the wedding feast she drives away, and the camera pulls out farther and farther; the many characters stroll through the landscape singly and move ever farther apart from one another. Another important link in society was the family. The central family in the film falls apart with the death of the mother. The left-wing father and his Fascist brother-in-law now no longer have any reason to stand by each other. After the funeral the father sits at home at the table, depressed. At the beginning of the film he had still gotten loudly worked up about the long faces at the table; now the table is empty. Titta leaves the house and goes to the sea; no ship picks him up there. He misses his mother and Gradisca. The spring fluff, “le manine,” drifts into the frame and reminds us of what lies ahead. Time moves on, spring comes, the witch will be burned again; sometime after that the Jews of Italy will be annihilated, too, and people like Uncle Teo, and leftists like Titta's father as well. The carnival is then over and Rimini sinks in flames. All that remains is the memory, “il ricordo,” and the dialect, in which Fellini says: “Amarcord.”