Living Colorfully and Showing Your Colors: A Film Commentary on Cabaret

Background
Christopher Isherwood was a British writer who went to Berlin in 1929, when he was in his mid-twenties. He was drawn by the liberal mood and the permissive nightlife there. “Berlin meant boys,” he said later; in Berlin he was looking for lovers. In Great Britain homosexuality was severely punished, by chemical castration among other things, as Alan Turing, for one, had suffered. Isherwood lived in Berlin from 1929 to 1933; for a long time he lodged at the Institute for Sexual Science. One love affair was so dear to him then that he stayed in Berlin in defiance of the danger until he saw himself forced to flee. In May 1933, then, he left Berlin and traveled to the US; that very month the Nazis plundered the institute's library and with it carried out their first great book burning.
The world in which Isherwood had had such a good time had perished. The people he had come to know in Berlin's nightlife would lose at least their way of life, often even their lives. That is why he wrote. He turned his memories into a loose collection of stories called “Goodbye to Berlin.” They form his testimony of that wildly liberal society in the midst of a steadily growing threat. Yet even outside Germany Isherwood did not dare to write with complete honesty. The many affairs and absolutely everything homosexual are banished between the lines, have to remain implicit. As a character in these stories he himself therefore seems detached. He writes: “I am a camera with its shutter open, quite passive; some day all this will have to be developed.”
The film was developed for him, literally. The interest in his glimpse of Berlin's prewar liberality – unique, because it became impossible after him – was enormous: his book became a play, and the play became a greatly expanded and colorfully staged stage musical by the legendary Broadway duo John Kander and Fred Ebb. For it his stories were slightly rewritten and expanded with new characters. The music of Kurt Weill, composer of The Threepenny Opera, was the main influence on the musical's songs. Isherwood's loose descriptions of Berlin nightlife became a stage called the Kit Kat Klub. A, shall we say, stage in Berlin founded in 1994 has famously taken up this name. I, too, prefer to remain implicit.
After the gifted dancer and star choreographer Bob Fosse had landed the job of bringing the musical to the screen, he changed the material once again: the Kit Kat Klub was now uncoupled from the plot and more central. The Emcee, that is, the club's master of ceremonies – in itself a free invention of Broadway – was kept and played in the film by the same stage actor.
The film “Cabaret” is thus a dream devised across time, in which the contours between the various influences blur. Isherwood's writing, alterations from Broadway and from Hollywood, Kurt Weill's socially critical jazz, sexual taboos and moralisms and, not least, reality flow together there. By reality I mean in the first place the connections to the lives of the artists involved: Bob Fosse had himself grown up in such disreputable cabarets; Liza Minnelli was the daughter of Judy Garland and therefore plagued by great stage ambitions and the failure of success to arrive, like Sally, her character in the film; Michael York had previously acted in stuffy Shakespeare adaptations under the direction of the pederast Franco Zeffirelli, and now plays the Isherwood character, named Brian; Joel Grey is a queer icon on Broadway and gets to put his singing and dancing skills fully on display, in his irrepressibly lively way, as the Emcee.
But in the second place the contours between the film's material and reality blur for me personally as well. The characters and the plot are, in part, too personally familiar. If for these reasons the film used to be my favorite film, it has now ceased to be a mere film: the far-right AfD leads the polls for the first time, with 25%; the US bans certain fields of research and deletes historical facts from government sources; lawmakers are shot; an open Hitler salute from a techno-fascist.
Willkommen, Bienvenue, Welcome – to reality.
Commentary
More concretely, this means that at this event here I would like to anticipate and put into perspective the pathologizing that is to be expected, of Sally in particular. Little can be said about Brian, except that he is socially awkward, is paralyzed by strong shame and yet seems to enjoy his passive presence in this permissive environment. When he is asked at one point to talk about himself, he is promptly interrupted by Sally, who incessantly performs herself. Because of this eternal self-presentation and self-praise, one could write Sally off as a young narcissist. I would counter that Sally still has to find herself at the beginning and is accordingly looking for role models. She has an obvious weakness when it comes to concentration, yet a strength for the interpersonal. Brian possesses a tolerance and a calm for which she envies him, and he offers her an excellent opportunity to bring him a little closer to knowledge of human nature and a taste for adventure. They are the relationship combination, by now almost a stereotype, of ADHD and mild Asperger's. Seen through less rose-tinted glasses, Brian's calm becomes crushing boredom for Sally, and Sally's taste for adventure becomes foolish infantility for Brian. At the end both still try to keep up a naive illusion of perfect romantic happiness. The scenes are as warming as they are pitiful. Of course the two are disillusioned. Sally's monologue on why she rejects the future with Brian is the first occasion on which she speaks in negative tones. Before that everything was “divine,” “marvelous” and “most significant” for her. She expressed herself, as people say nowadays, in toxic positivity. This shows most clearly in how she describes her father: he is at once super successful, dashing about all over the world, and yet takes a super lot of time for her. That she is forcibly whitewashing a good deal there, we then get to see for ourselves. The connection between her relationship with her father and her striving for affirmation from fatherly figures (casually called “daddy issues”) is really obvious. Only, in her dealings with men she fancies herself a clever seductress, even though her existence as a sugar baby does not lastingly remedy her materially subordinate role but in the end thoroughly confirms it.
But I do not want to go further than that. One can certainly attest to unwise conduct on Sally's part here and there, yes, but I do not want to call her behavior pathological, that is, sick. That goes for all forms of deviance in the film: the neurodivergence of the main characters already mentioned, the precarity, the alternative forms of relationship, the concentrated queerness. All of this has often been seen as vice, as illness. Erich Fromm warned early on that therapists run the risk of becoming the priests of capital. And it was precisely Freud who rejected the pathologizing of homosexuality. In the text “The Psychogenesis of a Case of Homosexuality in a Woman” he wrote that the status of illness mostly stems from the rejection of those around a person and does not come from within. In general, the status “sick” is exceedingly negative to this day. For the term is not applied like this: 'sick means suffering, so we are chosen to help the person' – that would be too Christian – but rather: 'sick is inherently wrong and thus morally inferior.' Discourses led by conservatives therefore try to argue their way to having deviant sexuality and gender identity classified as illness. An altogether better, well-funded and evidence-based treatment is not what is being sought. For divergent gender identities and behaviors were researched at Berlin's Institute for Sexual Science, which the Nazis plundered for that reason and whose books they set on fire. That book burning still has aftereffects today, for in many people's eyes transgender people are a new phenomenon or a fad. Yet that institute had produced a considerable corpus of research literature about them, which was lost precisely through this. The resulting historical amnesia was fully intended and was successful beyond the end of fascism. It is therefore no wonder that many people avoid any association with the idea of illness when, in the modern world, this status brings a witch burning in its wake.
Berlin's deviants are safe among their own kind in the cabaret. Things are inclusive here, for everything is beautiful and delightful and charming, even if, viewed conventionally – or fascistically – it would not be judged so. But is the function of the cabaret really that of a tolerant interior in which those who deviate are protected from the outside? I think the cabaret is there, for better and for worse, to let things blur. Different languages ring out there in alternation. The clownish Emcee – cheerful and yet always sadistic, similar in countenance to Joseph Goebbels and likewise a showmaster, and then again flamboyant in his queerness and thoroughly, permanently horny in his expression – connects seeming opposites. Our experience of gender is blurred in the cabaret shows. The cabaret is likewise a haven of high-class prostitution, a trade whose practitioners Stefan Zweig at that time called “amphibious beings,” because they practiced the lowly profession of singers and dancers and yet always peddled their wares in good society. The mixing of economic classes is constantly emphasized visually in the film. And so the cabaret seems at once seedy and yet also attractively different and new, for here there seems to be the chance of a reordering of things; a carnival that is apparently meant to last forever. That is why it is stressed so much at the beginning that there will be no troubles in the cabaret. Here, repression is the order of the day!
That, at least, is the claim; much more, the cabaret is the repressed that, as so often, returns. And it does so sometimes more, sometimes less symbolically. The melody of most of the songs is full of semitones. Already the Will-kom-men, Bien-ve-nue, Wel-come has several dissonant seconds. The tension and social disharmony are written into the music. The mud wrestling is likewise symbolic of the splitting of society, from which the Nazis above all profit, as the Emcee makes plain with his antics. Moreover, there is really a contradiction between “leave your troubles outside” and the songs, which sing very directly of money troubles and exclusion. In part they do so even more directly than the film's plot, in which the role of Max's wealth is not discussed directly until the very end, while the Emcee, intercut, reminds us of it with a smirk: it is about “Money.” And in any case, here the many deviants who are pushed out of the society outside find one another again in cheerful plurality.
On the whole, however, the plot leads away from the blurriness and plurality of the cabaret. By the end all the characters have declared who they are, and have marked themselves off from one another. Fritz Wendel has given up his turncoat ways and, of necessity, owned up to being Jewish. Max von Heune no longer associates with ordinary people. Brian returns to his solidly bourgeois ivory tower, King's College, Cambridge, where Alan Turing and John Maynard Keynes also studied and worked, respectively, at that very time. Sally, in turn, although she stays in the cabaret, does so because through the experience she has found her identity all the more strongly. For a force from outside is compelling the characters to put their cards on the table now: a force that has likewise strengthened its identity, that rejects plurality and now claims tomorrow entirely for itself.
This song, “Tomorrow Belongs to Me,” makes many qualities of the cabaret clearer once again by contrast. The song contrasts with the cabaret music through its long legatos, its always consonant harmonies and its even rhythm, whereas the cabaret tends toward staccato, employs, as mentioned, many dissonant chromatic melodies and syncopates a great deal. The cabaret concentrates on everything exciting, different and deviant, while the Nazis in the beer garden want to grip people and stir them up into unity. The beer garden in the film is, as a whole, a total work of art, as southern German as it is in design, located though it is in rural Brandenburg. The various people shown there are presumably meant to depict parts of society and how each reacts to the rise of fascism. But I am already commenting on the song far too analytically. Nothing should distract us from how incredibly powerful it is. The lyrics, a kitschy knockoff of Eichendorff's poetry, do not really have to make much sense. The music and the pathos simply unfold their effect ipso facto. It is therefore not surprising that several real fascist movements have already, completely without irony, taken up this song and used it for themselves. Among them the American neo-Nazi Richard Spencer, who tweeted the statement “Tomorrow belongs to us” together with a link to the song. John Kander's nephew answered with mockery and a correction. Kander and Ebb were themselves gay and Jewish, and used the song as a critique of ideology. Spencer showed himself unimpressed. For the bitter irony of it is: Spencer is presumably right all the same. The song is simply right. Pointing out logical inconsistencies is inadequate with fascists. With their songs as well as with their many pseudo-arguments. They rely not on logos but on pathos.
After this stormy anthem has rung out, the cabaret in the film gradually falls apart. The former director had still driven the Nazis out of the cabaret. After his intimidation or even murder, the cabaret now becomes more militaristic and openly anti-Semitic. But nobody really seems to notice; it is not commented on with a single word. How that can be is, in my opinion, clear. This quality of blurring boundaries also entails that the cabaret never stood for anything. Having exaggerated amounts of fun but wanting to stand for nothing – this aesthetic is called “camp.” Susan Sontag famously wrote that to talk about camp is to betray it. That makes sense to me, for anyone who interrupts this garish anti-intellectuality with critical questions might, after all, uncover the deep nihilism that always underlies a campy aesthetic. The last two songs, which claim that our troubles are now “forgotten,” which is of course nonsense, and that life is a carefree cabaret, show how problematic it has always been to want to believe in nothing.
The problem is this: you have to be able to afford nihilism. Someone in Sally's position gains nothing from walking campily past life. Sally's dreams of an acting career will vanish into thin air as soon as the Nazis choke off the German film industry. And then she is a penniless immigrant in Nazi Germany. Sally has missed everything political, literally slept through it, or was linguistically unable to read the signs. But camp, with its anti-intellectuality, also erodes solidarity and is socially irresponsible. As a modern bon mot from roughly that time already warns: "Those who stand for nothing, fall for anything." Nihilism saps the strength of those who would fight fascism and at the same time supports the radicalization of the others. It was precisely a flood of ironic internet memes that radicalized millions of young men. Eternal irony produces the absence of basic assumptions and of values; it produces nihilism. That in turn is dangerous breeding ground for all manner of things. For me it is therefore very fitting that in the film the Nazis do not abolish the cabaret at the end but are sitting in it themselves. It always worked in their favor. Nihilism can be afforded by those to whom everything else belongs.
And when those people then make up 25% of the audience, a return to fundamental values becomes vital. The camp aesthetic is far too strongly associated with queerness. In alternative queer circles I have experienced too often that people have already let themselves be completely depoliticized and stripped of solidarity. That they pursue, at most, a half-understood identity politics that in part works against solidarity and seriously gets in the way of no one with power; queer feminism does not in itself lack material issues and demands; but some queer-feminist people organize, for example, day raves as “alternative events” to the May Day demonstration, know practically nothing about real queer history and have chosen neoliberal rubbish as their aesthetic. Camp that long ago went mainstream and is politically toothless is not the answer to what is looming! Life is not a cabaret, after all, “old chum.” We should always ask critically, in the words of Florence Reece: “Which side are you on?”
Selected Bibliography
- Steven Belletto. “Cabaret and antifascist aesthetics.” Criticism 50.4 (2008): 609–630. (for a very clean and precise piece of craftsmanship with which, however, I disagree in places; the structural analyses of the cabaret that take the audience into account are brilliant.)
- Christopher Isherwood. 2014 [1939]. Leb Wohl, Berlin. Translated from the English by Kathrin Passig and Gerhard Henschel. Hamburg: Hoffmann und Campe Verlag. (my German edition, acquired 10 years ago, which I bought spontaneously because of the color of the cover and only read ten years later. The afterword is still as gloriously optimistic on political and social questions as has no longer been customary since 2016.)
- Contrapoints. “Opulence.” YouTube. October 12, 2019, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jD-PbF3ywGo (without explicit reference in the text; shaped my view of faux opulence such as Sally's; also shows a more benevolent view of camp than mine.)
- Into the Hoods. “Cabaret's Hidden Notes: Musical Warnings and Foreshadowing.” YouTube. September 14, 2024, https://youtu.be/7JP3UhdhslE (for the musical analysis.)
- Matt Baume. “Cabaret & the Seductive Power of Evil.” YouTube. June 2, 2024, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPpwXUZNbNs (the best and most multifaceted discussion of the film overall, with highly interesting background on the filmmakers and on queerness research in the 19th and early 20th centuries.)
- Moa Rambles. “Cabaret, Genderfuckery, and the Rise of Fascism.” YouTube. October 22, 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFudImQ9QEo (for the link to contemporary discourses.)
- Musicals w/ Cheese. “The Evolution of Cabaret.” YouTube. September 3, 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9YCefLcEYAk (for the perspective of musical connoisseurs on the different versions of the Cabaret material.)
- Sigmund Freud. 1920. “Über die Psychogenese eines Falles von weiblicher Homosexualität.” In: Internationale Zeitschrift für Psychoanalyse VI (1). Available here: https://archive.org/details/InternationaleZeitschriftFuumlrPsychoanalyseVi1920Heft1/page/n1/mode/2up. (for the problematizing of the concept of pathology in deviant sexuality.)
- Stefan Zweig. 2022 [1942]. Die Welt von Gestern. Erinnerungen eines Europäers. 6th edition. Berlin: Insel Verlag. The full text of a first edition(?) is available here: https://archive.org/stream/StefanZweigDieWeltVonGestern/Stefan%20Zweig%20-%20Die%20Welt%20von%20gestern_djvu.txt. (in the present text only for the comment on Viennese high-class prostitution around the turn of the century; but Zweig is always formative for my view of the history of morals, culture and much more.)