A Chase Through the Dream Labyrinth: A Film Commentary on Inception

Ariadne's thread

Background

Christopher Nolan is known for his obsessive film projects. Very often they are marked by a labyrinthine structure and have to be seen several times and untangled with detective work before you can understand what is shown at all. His research into the backgrounds of his films, whether biographical or technical in nature, is usually just as meticulous. On the subject of dreams his research was intensive, too, but here he explored only his own experience of them. For he discovered by chance, through external circumstances, that one can dream lucidly; that is, with full awareness that one is in a dream at that moment, and that one can also influence it. The external circumstances in question were the free breakfast at his student residence, which had to be eaten before nine o'clock, and his habit of working until four in the morning. So he set what was for him a very early alarm and always went straight back to bed after breakfast. What he would soon discover: such a rhythm increases the likelihood of a lucid dream. These lucid dreams, which Nolan calls a “superpower,” and his experiences in actively shaping his own dreams formed the central inspiration for his film “Inception.”

Wanting to approach the resulting film “Inception” with Freud's scientific theory of dreams is an interesting undertaking. On the one hand, Freud knew of the existence of lucid dreams and briefly commented on them – as well as on the conditions under which they arise – in his “Interpretation of Dreams.” Nolan, however, ignored Freud's scientific basis and relied solely on his own experiences. Commenting on the result from the perspective of Freud's thinking is therefore not redundant but rather dialogic: Nolan and Freud alike gained their knowledge from actively engaging with their own dreams; Nolan with artistic intentions, Freud with scientific ones.

I therefore think that Cinépassion, as a place for looking at films psychoanalytically, is an apt setting for this film. For that reason I would like to explain a little, even before the film, how dreams work in general and specifically in this film. To this end I subjected myself to a crash course in Freudian dream theory given by my brother Volker; I owe him a great deal for further Freudian input as well. My hope is that this will make the film somewhat less labyrinthine and thus give you an altogether better, because more lucid, film experience. The alternative, accordingly, is that you lose yourself in the action-packed film dream and forget it soon afterward.

First, there is the basic rule that all conscious sensory content in dreams is the fulfillment of wishes. These wishes, however, are often repressed, which is why resistances to them exist; the form in which wishes are fulfilled in dreams is mostly distorted. It is also important that wish fulfillments can turn up in dreams spontaneously and surprisingly. Yet not everything in a dream serves this principle of wish fulfillment. So-called secondary revision is the conscious thought process within the conscious dream. It finds connections of thought between the dream contents, so that a dream is experienced as coherent to varying degrees. In lucid dreams secondary revision is at its strongest, so that dreams like the ones you are about to see in the film are very coherent. In that respect, then, the film is realistic.

To be precise, Inception is a science fiction film. Close to reality, but with a fictional technology that works in a lawful and predictable way: shared dreaming. This technology is explained only rather meagerly in the film; one rule is even withheld entirely. So a brief introduction is needed:

In shared dreaming there are different roles; I use the English expressions from the film's original audio. There is, first, the Architect, who has designed the dream scenery. Into this world the Target is abducted, that is, the person the mission is aimed at. The Target populates the world laid out by the Architect, so that the passersby, for example, are produced by the Target's unconscious. If the Architect has provided an especially secure place in the design, a safe for instance, the Target fills it with information worth protecting, with secrets. The abductors can now break in there and thus get at the Target's secrets.

The central figure, however, is the Dreamer. It is in the Dreamer's dream that the scenery designed by the Architect is used and into which the Target is abducted. Thanks to this special position, the Dreamer also has heroic abilities there; he is the “James Bond” of his dream.

The twist in the film will be that shared dreaming is in fact also used inside a dream. The Architect can provide another scenery, the Target can be drawn onto this scenery into a new dream within the dream, and someone else will then be the “James Bond” there. The latter is important: the Dreamer of a dream can not go into the next-deeper dream; his task will be to keep the original dream stable.

And that, all in all, is my thread for you as you are about to walk through the labyrinth: keep in mind who the Dreamer is and which assumptions the Target makes in each case, populating the dream worlds accordingly. That will help to untangle the complex mesh of dreams within other dreams.

And I hope – this must not be forgotten either – that you will also have some fun with the film!

Commentary

I think I did not promise too much. Inception is complex and nested. For one thing because of the constantly branching main plot of the inception; for another there is the subplot revolving around Cobb and his late wife Maud; and then the film uses all sorts of symbols and action. My commentary will first of all untangle the main plot, based on several attentive viewings.

The airplane setting shows us reality. There the team around Cobb falls asleep together with Fisher in a shared dream. The dreamer is the chemist Yusuf. It quickly turns out, however, that Fisher's projections of resistance have been militarized, that is, specifically trained in dream defense. The risk is that death in the dream will not wake you up here but drop you into limbo. In that state you run the danger of becoming demented if you remain in it too long. For the audience this creates suspense, because the mission now hangs by a thread. At least they have gotten hold of Fisher. The work of suggesting to him that he should not take up his inheritance now begins.

For this purpose the rainy city is used as a pseudo-reality: Fisher is made to believe here that he and Peter, his father's confidant, have been kidnapped. Peter is actually an illusion here; in truth it is the team member Eames speaking. As Peter he tells Fisher of an alternative will that is supposedly hidden in a secret safe and according to which the father's corporate empire would be broken up. This lie, as I said, counts for Fisher from then on as supposed reality when he is taken to the next-deeper dream level. That is decisive because it is there that the risky maneuver is carried out in which the dream is revealed as such. While the team glides down there with Arthur as Dreamer, the Dreamer Yusuf performs his heroic feats of driving for the rest of the film and will trigger the kick on time.

The second dream level, in the hotel, is then the most complicated. Cobb poses as head of security and convinces Fisher that he is being followed. In the restroom Cobb eliminates Fisher's projections of resistance and searches them, thereby making Fisher believe that these were the kidnappers. Cobb then helps Fisher to remember the kidnapping in the rainy “waking world”: the kidnappers wanted a number. This makes the deception more credible. They break into room 528, which the team had of course prepared. There they find the shared-dream apparatus – Cobb claims the kidnappers wanted to put Fisher into a dream again. When a man with Peter's appearance then enters the room, that is, for once, not part of the plan. It is Fisher's own projection of Peter, though Fisher does not know it. The conversation with the projected Peter is in itself a soliloquy in which Peter is portrayed the way Fisher already thought of him, even if not quite consciously. Peter's supposed intention of destroying the secret will now makes this preconscious view conscious. But the point now is for Fisher to arrive at the insight, regardless of whether it is true or not, that his father had wished the inheritance not to be taken up. To obtain this supposed secret knowledge, Cobb proposes that the team could penetrate Peter's unconscious by way of shared dreaming. They do so, only it is by no means Peter who is the Dreamer, but Eames. Fisher will enter the fortress believing he is uncovering Peter's secrets, and in doing so will only go deeper into himself, since his unconscious will fill the fortress, as a secure place in Eames's dream, with content.

On the whole the feint works; after yet more armed resistance and the risky detour via limbo, Fisher arrives at what he takes to be Peter's secret but what is really a fulfillment of his own wishes: his father's trust and the encouragement to go his own way. This information is marked by the pinwheel that Fisher had presumably once given his father. What exactly the pinwheel means is not known to Cobb's team: for the team and the viewers this is the navel of the dream. What is clear, however, is that finding the pinwheel leads to intense emotion in Fisher, which reinforces the implanting of the thought that the projection of his father speaks aloud.

The procedure of getting Fisher to give himself the implanted thought is remarkable. It also recalls a technique of psychoanalytic treatment that Freud set down in 1912 in the text “The Dynamics of Transference”: “We take care of the patient's independence by using suggestion to have him carry out a piece of psychical work that has as its necessary consequence a lasting improvement of his psychical situation.”

Whether the suggestion has now led, in Fisher's case, to an improvement of his psychical situation or to a fulfilling career – or to an improvement of the client's situation – the film leaves open. The one who obviously does experience a psychical healing, by contrast, is the abductor Cobb himself!

Central here is the relationship between Ariadne and Cobb: she takes on a therapeutic role toward him insofar as she supports Cobb in overcoming his symptoms and thus, in the end, his illness. It is this relationship, and the working through of Cobb's past connected with it, that you can follow comparatively easily as a viewer and that guides you through the film. A decisive moment is when Ariadne learns that Cobb has preserved the memories of his wife in a memory archive. She therefore demands of him that Cobb either let Arthur in on it or let her take part in the operation. Cobb agrees to the latter. At the end of the operation she is then the one who has the idea for saving the situation and who finally helps Cobb to overcome his symptom and with it his illness. By symptom is meant here the projection of his late wife Maud, who constantly sabotages his work. That already happens in the very first dream, in which the extraction of information from Saito fails because of her. The symptom does not, however, always appear only in this form. It also appears in the form of his children and, right at the start of the mission, as an out-of-place train in the rainy city.

As I said in the introduction, perceptual contents in dreams arise according to the logic of wish fulfillment; and often precisely as distorted wish fulfillments. With this knowledge the train can be interpreted. Later in the film we learn that Cobb and his wife freed themselves from limbo by letting themselves be run over by this very train. Correspondingly, the train also nearly runs over Cobb. On the one hand the wish to wake up shows itself here; on the other hand the wish to be together with his wife in limbo shows itself, too, since the train appeared in the last moment in which they were together in limbo. As we see later in the film, Maud cried out shortly before the train struck them: “Because we will be together.” In this way the train is a compromise between these two wishes.

But why does Cobb have the wish to wake up? Well, he has led his team into a highly dangerous operation without anyone knowing it. We may assume that he has a guilty conscience about this and, in reaction, the wish to undo the situation, that is, to wake up. The guilty conscience leads in turn to a wish for punishment, which likewise finds satisfaction in Cobb's almost being hit by the locomotive. The motive of the symptom, to sabotage Cobb's work, is also expressed in the locomotive. The English expression “to derail something” means, literally, to make something leave the rails, and figuratively, to make something planned fail or come apart.

The deeper Cobb descends into the dream levels, the more directly he is confronted with his symptom. In Eames's dream it turns up as Maud, and she sabotages his work by shooting Fisher. In response Cobb manages to shoot her. When he and Ariadne go into limbo, he then has to face his wife once more. There he can finally tell how her death had actually come about. It is then Maud who sheds tears over it. That the wish to be together with Maud in limbo was the cause of the sabotage of Cobb's work is then also shown by the fact that Maud only consents to let Fisher go after Cobb promises to stay in limbo. Ariadne is at first shocked by this, but Cobb explains that he has to do it because he still has to find Saito and get him out of limbo. Before Ariadne uses the kick to wake up in Eames's dream, she performs her last therapeutic act: she shoots Maud and in this way helps Cobb to let her die and so finally to detach himself from her.

There remains one question to be settled, however. How did the symptom from which Cobb suffered manifest itself in waking life? Strictly speaking, one can only speculate about that, since we get to see only a little of Cobb's waking life. A plausible answer, though, is: Cobb's recurring doubts as to whether he is awake or dreaming.

The doubt as to whether he is awake is so strong that he has to use Maud's totem to reassure himself. This is striking, for a totem is not actually necessary for checking whether one is awake or dreaming. There are numerous techniques for this that can be applied at any time. You can try to breathe through your nose while holding it shut. In a dream that is possible without any trouble. You can also look at written characters. These blur or, on closer inspection, make no sense. Testing whether you are awake is thus not especially difficult. A dream expert like Cobb, of all people, would need no totems whatsoever for it. Strictly speaking, what a totem tests is whether he is in a dream of his own or in someone else's. That is the reason why nobody else may know how a totem is constituted, for otherwise you could be abducted into someone else's dream in which the totem works correctly, and you become vulnerable to extractions and manipulations à la Cobb. That he uses the spinning top instead of his own totem, however, is an expression of his unconscious identification with Maud. For as long as the top spins, he is in Maud's position, and the wish that he be dreaming is satisfied. These are thus less moments of an actual testing of reality – he could test that more easily and more quickly – than moments of bringing Maud back to life by taking her position.

But that is over now. In the last moments of the film the top is spinning again. Yet Cobb completely forgets to pay it any attention. He leaves the top behind, just as he leaves behind the grief for his wife, now worked through. The music accompanying Cobb's way home already made it clear that all tensions and opposing wishes are now resolved. The top begins to wobble, and the film now lets us, too, wake into reality. In the reception of the film, however, the one big question that is mostly discussed – mostly so extensively that there is hardly any room for other topics of conversation – is whether Cobb is awake or dreaming at the end. That, remarkably, is exactly the question Cobb asked himself again and again over the course of the film when he was haunted by his symptom. So what has presumably happened there? I interpret it this way: the viewers, having for their part entered into an identification with Cobb, have taken over the symptom that Cobb left behind on the table and transfer it to the reception of the film. If the wish to understand the film is disappointed, this doubt can at least serve as a substitute satisfaction. But we no longer depend on that. We are allowed to wake up now. Stay woke!