The Illuminated Screen: The Vatican's Film Recommendations

On the subject of cinema, too, the Vatican has tried to keep up. It is generally assumed that cinema began in December 1895 with the projections of the Lumière brothers. In 1995, then, cinema's hundredth birthday was coming up. Archbishop John P. Foley drew up a detailed plan for how the Vatican would mark the celebration: a film festival, several official declarations and publications, an officially blessed film canon and the appointment of a patron saint for cinema. Now, it so happens that a few years ago, in my role as head of a cinema, I googled which saint I might put on my desk. The search yielded nothing; to this day cinema has no patron saint.
How that came about – or rather how the appointment of the saint did not come about – is told to us by one of the people responsible for this plan, Román Gubern. He is one of Spain's greatest contemporary intellectuals; a jurist, a historian and, not least, a media theorist and film connoisseur. In a little book published in 2020 he recounts, in a spirited and entertaining way, what the whole experience of serving the Vatican as a film expert was like. There, for example, it is told for the first time why in the end no patron saint for cinema was appointed after all. The committee had drawn up a shortlist in the form of a trio: Saints Francis of Assisi, Don Giovanni Bosco and Maximilian Kolbe. When Gubern told a journalist friend about this project, a storm broke out in the press, full of mockery and malice. The only way out of this snafu was to drop the undertaking. And yet a patron saint of cinema is not so far-fetched at all! The tabloid press mocked by proposing an Italian porn actress well known at the time. That is of course harsh mockery of cinema. But the joker also fails to recognize that the Catholic Church appoints patron saints for absolutely everyone, including prostitutes. And that some saints were prostitutes themselves. But it was no use; the mockery was enough to have the plan called off from the very top. Now the internet will presumably get a patron saint sooner than cinema.
Otherwise, though, the celebration of cinema took place as planned. And the film canon was successfully put together. The canon comes across as apparently well considered: it consists of three thematic lists, each with 15 entries. The lists are themed around religious values, moral and humanistic values, and artistic values. The making of these lists, however, was far less meticulously planned than it might seem. Initially the assumption was a single list, which Gubern presented as a basis for discussion. But the debates about it were not long in coming. Two questions above all dominated the committee's discussion: Are enough different people represented? Just think in how many different countries Catholics live. The second question concerned the convictions of the directors: a Catholic film canon with atheists, homosexuals, Marxists, racists and even Protestants? This criticism, however, came mainly from other quarters in the Vatican; the committee itself preferred to judge the films as such and to forgive the directors everything. Still, the question was whether to list exclusively directors from Christian cultures or to be as diverse as possible.
Diversity of countries and cultures was a declared aim, but the committee did not adjust its course all that convincingly. To make the diversity of cultures clear, it divided the original list in two, into a clearly Christian-oriented list and one for the rest. This rest, however, was a mixture of spiritually motivated films and simply celebrated classics. That is how the three-way division came about into Christian values, non-Christian spiritual/moral values and great artistic achievements. The lists can only partly be called inclusive, though: the diversity of faiths among the directors is representative of the European continent, but not much more. Gubern himself admits that a cold shiver of fear was palpable in the committee at the idea of having to watch dozens or hundreds of obscure film suggestions from every corner of the globe. I know the feeling. It is simply more pleasant to walk paths that have already been opened up. It is not necessarily the rule of old gentlemen that determines our canons; rather, it is simply uncomfortable to set foot on terrain that has not yet been explored and leveled. And so the committee, too, stayed rather comfortable; the mere fact that I had already seen a good half of the selected films when I learned of the list shows its clear orientation toward established classics. Most of the films unknown to me were from Italy and not particularly good – the Roman bias was, as so often, hard to overcome. The lists offer ample targets for the contemporary critique of canons. That the Vatican was aware of this is shown by the title of the list: Alcuni film importanti (“some important films”).
Canons sometimes have a terrible reputation. They are said to preserve patriarchy, Eurocentrism and the colonialism bound up with it, and a whole host of other isms besides. I nevertheless think it wrong to want to draw up no canons at all. For one thing, you can make better and worse canons – purpose-bound ones and more general ones, too – and anyway: canons create identity. In my opinion, the answer to canons with an outdated worldview has to consist of new, diverse, iconoclastic canons – without forgetting to praise older works as well that still point the way today.
So I started a spare-time project to finish watching this canon. Was it worth it? Well, the average rating of the films new to me was a mere 6.15/10, but with a relatively high variance of about 3. Highlights among the new discoveries were The Burmese Harp and Babette's Feast. Nazarin and Thérèse were heavier films, but good for one's personal horizon. Lowlights were a clunky silent film from 1905, the awkwardly told Monsieur Vincent and the super-stuffy Little Women adaptation from 1933.
In what follows I rhapsodize on the three lists and comment above all on the surprising films and the ones worth seeing.
Artistic values
Average rating: 7.13/10; variance: 1.7
This list is defined purely by quality. It is important to stress that good spiritual work consists in meeting the world as it is. Listening before judging, describing before prescribing. Contrary to certain prejudices, the Church does not wall itself off. With Citizen Kane and Otto e Mezzo, this list names great and important titles; children's films are represented, too, with Fantasia and The Wizard of Oz. But I miss Studio Ghibli films that already existed in 1995: Grave of the Fireflies, say, for the ethical messaging, or My Neighbor Totoro. The Wizard of Oz is nice enough, but truly not the pinnacle of children's cinema (and it was made under inhumane working conditions). The silent era is well represented with Napoleon and Metropolis, but Man with a Movie Camera is quite clearly missing, without which any canon of the best films is incomplete. There would have been room for it, in my opinion, since with the Little Women of the 1930s and The Lavender Hill Mob, artistically inconsequential films were selected. A preference for older films is noticeable, 2001: A Space Odyssey from 1968 being the most recent film on the list.
It is admittedly the most difficult list, since 15 places are nowhere near enough. As the canon as a whole is, after all, called “some important films,” one can at least say: yes, important these films all are, at any rate.
Moral and humanistic values
Average rating: 7.06/10; variance: 1.1
A colleague of mine made a good observation: aesthetics played a role in the two value-driven lists as well. Intolerance, for example, is a weak film in terms of content (for four hours the director gets worked up about having been criticized for glorifying racist lynchings), yet it is visually impressive. Something similar applies to Chariots of Fire, which does not deliver the most comprehensive critique of anti-Semitism but certainly one of the most aesthetically impressive. Marxist neorealism is included for its ethical reflections (Ladri di biciclette, Roma città aperta). With Dersu Uzala and Wild Strawberries there are, moreover, absolute masterpieces on the list that engage quite effortlessly with great human questions. Complementing them is Kieślowski's Dekalog, which, with its almost Soviet-realist aesthetic, delivers ten ethical dilemmas by way of the Ten Commandments; a must on this list.
What is especially nice, too, is that the list does not only model values. The Tree of Wooden Clogs is a three-hour look into the lives of simple peasants in the 19th century. Presumably the clergymen liked how the peasants keep to their calendar of prayer and care for one another. But the film is also marked by exploitation and the precarious conditions that result from it. And that in turn makes human togetherness and spirituality harder.
With Gandhi and The Burmese Harp, Hinduism and Buddhism are each represented, the former being a conventional Hollywood picture, while the latter really gripped and surprised me.
Religious values
Average rating: 6.76/10; variance: 5.2
What stands out immediately: the religious picks are pretty lit!, if mixed. Here we have the epics Andrei Rublev and Ben-Hur, the classics Ordet and La Passion de Jeanne d’Arc, and works that were new to me then but brilliant, such as Babette's Feast. With Thérèse the list even ventures into surrealism, and with The Mission it also addresses the Vatican's mistakes and how economic interests cut off spiritual work. This point becomes very clear when Liam Neeson and Jeremy Irons play Jesuits who defend indigenous tribes by force of arms against the Portuguese troops. Moreover, the directors on this list are among the most daring: while ethically ambivalent directors and many people of other faiths were to be expected on the previous lists, it is on the religious list of all places that we have two films by a Soviet (Tarkovsky), one by Buñuel (doesn't really fit into any ideological drawer) and one by Pier Paolo Pasolini (communist and queer). The first two, despite their backgrounds, were strongly interested in religion; the last, however, is presumably the crowning glory of the list: his Gospel According to St. Matthew is the ideal adaptation of the story of Jesus, entirely without stuffy or kitschy ornament. Here you really have the feeling of reading the original text as it spontaneously generates images. The director's identity provoked the left and the right alike at the time, yet here Pasolini is the mouthpiece of a much older and politically more subversive message.
It is only a pity that a silent Gospel film from 1905 was selected as well. The reasoning was that, under the technical conditions of the time, producing 40 coherent minutes of film was laborious in the extreme, particularly because every single frame was colored by hand. This, it was said, proves a passionate devotion to the Gospel. Even so, I simply find it ridiculous how every take could be one minute long at most; as a result the Last Supper becomes a rapid procedure of sitting down, waving bread and wine about, standing up again and walking out of the frame. This film and Monsieur Vincent (as well as a universally beloved film that I cannot stand) drag the overall rating of the list down quite far, which shows in the high variance of my ratings.
Conclusion
So how good is this film canon? Well, its main weakness is the strong bias toward Italian films, which harms the whole list because it means less variation and fewer surprises. The list of “artistic values” is good, but somewhat dusty and stuffy. The list of “human and moral values” is more interesting and has hardly any weaknesses. The religious list is the most exciting and holds many a surprise and masterpiece. As an overall conclusion I would say that the Vatican has proven itself here above all as an intellectual authority and has given many films and people a recognition they definitely deserved. In doing so it leapt over its own shadow a good deal and gave recognition in places that many might misunderstand as enemy territory for Catholics. So not an all-round canon, but, specifically from the Catholic point of view, an interesting foundation stone for fresh cinephiles. Best of all, of course, would be a Catholic film magazine that regularly continues these discussions and tributes, so as not to stop at a list that is noticeably dated and in part one-sided.