Loose Thoughts on Kindergarten

The Froebel gifts
Detours that you stumble upon by chance and that turn out to be endlessly deep are wonderful. So-called "rabbit holes," as people like to call them today, after Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland. The other day, for example, I was busy researching one of my favorite bands from my youth when I got stuck on their song "Kindergarten." "All I know / I learned in / Kindergarten," goes the chorus. That thought set off quite a lot in me; I, too, associate many strong feelings with my kindergarten years. I was a consistent loner and a child lost in thought. I spent hours on the close study of shapes, of connections between space and optics, of the different qualities of sounds, of the strange language of the Upper Bavarian kindergarten children, and of what I was trying to learn about the world from recently watched films. The kindergarten teachers told my mother about my somewhat peculiar ways. But they assured her that in my development I was in no way behind what was expected at my age. I was simply an eager thinker.

And that is why the line of the song resonated with me so much. There are thoughts that I still count as part of my worldview today and that I first formed in my kindergarten. One big topic for me was the (un)reality of social conventions. I observed which procedures I was being taught that had no material necessity in themselves. Politeness, for instance, or the order of activities – you weren't allowed into the play corner until everyone had finished their handicrafts, even if you yourself had been quicker. Decency demanded it – or the many rules about what you were allowed or required to play when. I still remember that I even suspected the value of money to be something that is not inherently valuable but exists as a collectively agreed, socially emergent quality.

My kindergarten years really mean a lot to me. Again and again, moments from them come to mind and help me understand my present a little better.

But something else, too, stirred my thoughts about kindergarten. The American band writes the title as "Kindergarten," that is, with a <t>. And indeed that is how the word is written everywhere in the US. People do pronounce -garten with a soft /d/, but in writing they keep the word exactly as in German. Furthermore: the word "Kinder" is in no way part of the English vocabulary. The word "kindergarten" is thus a loanword that speakers probably do not grasp in its component parts. A little like iceberg, which is presumably not understood as a "mountain of ice," since Berg is not an English word. And indeed I find a comment on Reddit by a parent who grasps only in the very moment of commenting what kindergarten actually stands for.

I go through translations of "Kindergarten" in other languages and see yet more languages besides English that have adopted the word as is, or at least as a loan translation: Russian, Greek, Hindi, Bengali, Malay, …

Long-haired hippie, preacher of grassroots-democratic pedagogy, nature-spiritual understander of children: Friedrich Fröbel, inventor of the kindergarten

The reason for this is plain and simple: the kindergarten does not come from nowhere; it comes from Germany. It is an invention of the German educator Friedrich Fröbel. The more I find out about him, the more interesting and personally touching this rabbit hole becomes. Fröbel wore his hair unusually long, even though he came from the early 19th century. His portraits all accentuate his hooked nose and his gentle gaze. You trust this man at once. He looks kindly and eccentric in a cheerful way. Of course someone like that invented the kindergarten! But in the 19th century this eccentricity is not entirely innocent: after the failed revolution of 1848, the German emperor tries to weaken everything democratic in the country. Fröbel's concept of a place of care where all(!) children enjoy a basic education was, in the eyes of the reactionaries, thoroughly subversive and dangerous! Nowadays the sight of a kindergarten is something purely everyday. You expect, as a matter of course, to come across a kindergarten in every small town, in every residential neighborhood and at regular intervals in the countryside. It is also telling how heterogeneous the countries are in which kindergartens exist: these countries differ in religion, political structure and history; and yet all agree that the kindergarten is a good and useful thing. In Fröbel's day, however, his concept was a political issue; it was unheard of to want to offer something like pedagogy and care even to the children of poor families. Fröbel was the Lenin of early childhood education!

For this reason kindergartens were banned throughout Germany, and the kindergarten teachers already trained by Fröbel found themselves forced to continue their work abroad. Ironically, it is the banning of the kindergarten in the German Reich that turned it into Germany's lasting top export hit.

I can, however, understand on some level why Fröbel's kindergartens were a thorn in the side of the authoritarians. Fröbel was not quiet or conflict-averse in how he expressed himself. He postulated and downright preached when it came to concepts of pedagogy. Alongside the education of children he also advanced the education of women, and with thoroughly democratic pathos: educating people, and indeed all people, he saw as an important step toward a freer and altogether better society. In the kindergarten, according to him, grows the enlightened society of tomorrow.

And for this reason Fröbel's statements are a sociopolitical treasure chest in which you see the many Enlightenment and naturalistic ideals of the age reflected:

"The school as an institution for the acquisition of a greater or lesser quantity of manifold things, and therefore of externals, by no means makes the school a school; only the spiritual, living breath that animates all things, in which all things move, does so."

Fröbel thus regards school as a spiritual mission in which nothing less is at stake than the one eternal and universal life energy!

"In education one must bring something out of a person, not put something into them."

"Children are like flowers. You have to bend down to them if you want to know them."

Here, too, we sense the idea of the breath of life. There is already much within a child, as much as in nature itself. The point, he says, is to find this muchness and greatness in the child; THAT is education. You also notice a dig at authoritarian top-down thinking when his "top-down" is the movement toward the supposedly lower subject. Coming down to eye level. Very likable!

"In play the child discovers the world and itself."

"The source of all that is good lies in play."

"Play is the highest form of development."

I revere Fröbel for these statements! It is a dark side of the modern world that so little importance is attached to play. Pseudo-intellectuals often consider themselves too refined to do sports or to enjoy them as a spectacle. Many people who intellectualize by halves, without any curiosity or sincere thinking-through of their positions, like to look down on video games. Carnivals such as Pride parades or techno festivals are eyed critically from all sides and scolded with a raised, moralizing finger. But I very much agree with Friedrich Fröbel that without play we would never understand ourselves and the world. And that is of infinite importance precisely at a young age! And later, too – this is my ceterum censeo – a human being must play!

But besides play, his kindergarten was also there for work. The children were to be taught basic skills, especially in dealing with nature. Here, too, the idea of the universal experience of life dominates:

"For school is indeed the highest thing, but only when it is life."

"Religion without industry, without work, runs the risk of becoming empty dreaming, vain enthusiasm, a phantom without substance, just as work and industry without religion turn a person into a beast of burden, into a machine."

You notice the delicate interplay of a religiously oriented work ethic and a wish for a meaningful and beneficial education. And the last part of the last quotation in particular has a political ring. Yes, one should work, but one runs the risk of being exploited as a beast of burden and a machine. Fröbel continues to stress maturity and emancipation as a human being.

"But man is not alone in the world; the whole external world is the object of his knowing and the means of his development and education."

"Thus work, instruction and play shall become one unfragmented whole of life and the foundation of a future undivided, vigorous, insightful and joyful life."

"The smallest seed carries the great whole within itself and develops it in connection with the great whole of life. So I, too, as a human being carry within me the whole past, the fullness of the present and the riches of the future."

Friedrich Fröbel gave the children in his kindergartens a gift in which all these ideas subtly echo. The so-called Froebel gifts are a case full of geometric shapes made of wood. Even the material is thoroughly political here: wood was cheap and plentiful, so the Froebel gifts could be produced in large numbers. The result is a uniform aesthetic that is appealing nonetheless. This was imitated, for example by Carl Orff with his children's instruments. The purpose of the geometric shapes is to awaken curiosity about building and combining. The Froebel gifts are accompanied by tasks intended for children of different ages. Over time the children are to learn more and more to form the shapes into more complex structures and to solve harder tasks with them.

As a companion to an education close to nature, the Froebel gifts are an introduction to human thinking. The shapes are abstract; they are thoughts you can touch. And they convey the world as something that can be divided into modules, understood and imitated. And that can be explored as play!

And here my rabbit hole reached a climax: once the kindergartens had been banned in Germany, some of the kindergarten teachers emigrated, among other places, to the US. The ideas – religiously motivated but not overdetermined, and democratically oriented – met with great approval there. They spread everywhere in the States, including rural areas. And in a small community in Wisconsin, a certain child in a newly established kindergarten took quite particular delight in the "Froebel Gifts." It played with them eagerly and sketched its little constructions. It kept developing this fascination, and later this child, by then known as Frank Lloyd Wright, became a celebrated architect. And Wright continued to say that he still saw the Froebel gifts in his mind's eye.

And I came across the Froebel gifts elsewhere, too. The gifted animation filmmaker Hayao Miyazaki is known for his empathetic children's films, but also for his strong opinions on matters of upbringing. For the employees of his animation studio he personally designed a kindergarten and had it built. The children there are meant to be outdoors as much as possible and to learn many practical skills. I think there is more than a mere coincidental parallel here. Miyazaki's career started, among other things, with Heidi, for which his employer also financed trips to Switzerland. It stands to reason that in-depth research into the development of pedagogy at that time was in the budget as well. The author of the Heidi story, Johanna Spyri, constantly renders the spirit of that time in her text: nature is emphasized, as are the inherent quality of the child and of childhood and the important role of empathy. From here it is truly not far to Fröbel. In fact you only need to look into Miyazaki's latest film, "The Boy and the Heron."

Film still from "The Boy and the Heron" by Hayao Miyazaki

In the film there is a character whose role is not clearly declared but who can vaguely be seen as the eldest scholar and protector of the fantasy world. His task of keeping the world in balance is symbolized by white geometric figures that the scholar stacks on top of one another again and again without their toppling over.

Since here, too, thoughts of a universal, inner force of the world arise, and since Miyazaki in all probability learned of Fröbel's philosophy, I declare the following as the first person on the internet (and thus probably anywhere): the figures in "The Boy and the Heron" are Froebel gifts!

And here this rabbit hole ends for the time being. A good moment to go outside and play a little in the open air, isn't it? For faith and for democracy 😉